skip nav  
 


Carlton Tavern, York

back to pub details

user reviews of the Carlton Tavern, York

please note - reviews on this site are purely the opinion of site visitors, so don't take them too seriously.

GREAT PUB! PREVIOUS BAD REVIEWS ARE VERY OUTDATED IN MY OPINION CASK ALES AVAILABLE INCLUDING MY FAVOURITE HOBGOBLIN! LOVELY PINT MY PAL OPTED FOR THE PEDIGREE AND ENJOYED HIS.GOOD MENU AND VALUE FOR MONEY HAD THE STEAK DEAL AND THE JAM ROLY POLY WAS DELICIOUS NICE FRIENDLY STAFF " NOT A CHAV INSIGHT." WILL BE VISITING AGAIN WITH FRIENDS AND FAMILY NICE PLACE JUST IN NEED OF REDECORATION.
TINKBERRY - 25 Mar 2013 01:57
As Camerons no longer, thank God, have anything to do with the Carlton we can ignore the comments referring to them. It was with a pretty deep suspicion that I went to the pub after the change of ownership. OK the decoration is pretty tired, but the staff and the food have improved out of all knowledge as has the beer. Marston's pedigree is a first class pint and the price is good into the bargain both for the food and the drink.
Finney144 - 18 Dec 2010 13:51
After living out of the area for 3 years or so, I payed a a visit to this pub last Sunday & have to say was pleasently suprised. Since my last visit the pool table, juke box and sky tv have been removed and it is now alot more comfortable. The carvery available was very nice & the Pedigree cask on top form. Also noticable was the distinct reduction of tracksuits and baseball caps, not one in sight. I will be back there on a regular basis.
rustypistol - 12 Jul 2010 17:19

@oneofthekingsmen - Camerons is brewed in Hartlepool. Name me some of the other "crap things" to have come out of Sunderland......

BTW I also dislike this place intensely, an amusement arcade masquerading as a pub.
Yorkmackem - 27 Feb 2010 12:22
What a horrible place this is. We visited as a family group last Sunday - a relative had made the booking on the basis of accessibility for all. Big mistake. The "food" was inedible, the whole place filthy, the staff ignorant and unhelpful, and the customers in general looked as though they had just been released from a high security prison. To add insult to injury the snow hadn't been cleared from the driveway or car park and there were people falling all over the place.
sc_staples - 23 Dec 2009 15:15
This is the worst pub and place i have ever stayed in. I actually stayed in the "hotel" appartments at the rear of this pub which were like under a bridge in downtown harlem. The rooms smell of damp and rotten woodwork, foundations and previous tennants. The toilets and taps did not work and when this was complained about the little upstart of a manager just huffed and puffed (what a looser). The windows did not shut properly and were rotten anyway. The whole place was disgusting with insects and filth in all parts of the rooms. I dod not expect too much at �35 per night but this place was pure filth and smelt of mould.

The pub had a few locals in who were dressed in their local best of jogging bottoms, vests, cheap bling and screaming down their mobile phones because they want to get attention. The food was not even tried by any of our party as we got a glimpse of the kitchens which looked like a latrine after a bout of stomach ache. DO NOT STAY at this place it is rotten to the core and a disgrace to the hotel industry. It needs to be shut down.
Andicheese - 6 Aug 2009 12:37
Does W Boyd still get in the bar, years since I have been in the place was a good bar.
millwall - 12 Jun 2007 11:12
This "pub" if you can call it that is a disgrace. Full of halfwits and ladyboys.
big_baby_jesus - 18 Dec 2006 17:58
That's just not true - you can get away with big gold dangly earings if you are a lass!
Has rapidly gone down hill in the last few years, used to be a different place to go for a quick local drink, not anymore. Never did like the Camerons beer that they sell, another crap thing to have come out of Sunderland.
Although you can hire the conservatory out for your wedding reception. Why??
oneofthekingsmen - 1 Dec 2006 18:42
Dress code is tracksuit and chav cap. NO exceptions !
daveleetravis - 28 Dec 2005 18:08

got anything to say about this pub?

Please read our reviews policy before posting.
Only registered users can post reviews. Please log in. If you don't have an account yet, register here.