Blythe Hill Tavern, Forest Hill

back to pub details

user reviews of the Blythe Hill Tavern, Forest Hill

please note - reviews on this site are purely the opinion of site visitors, so don't take them too seriously.

Very friendly pub which, like previous reviewer, I checked out following its CAMRA success. A proper locals pub full of old boys and tracksuited geezers watching the golf. The sort of place you could easily while away a day in, particularly with the beautifully kept pints of Freedom ale and Hophead.
JonW999 - 21 Sep 2008 09:25
Having lived in the area for years and walked past the door without going in ever, I was intrigued when it won our Camra Branch pub of the year. I can see why; lovely garden; unspoiled interior; beers in top nick (Landlord, Harvey's Best and Westerham Summer Perle when I last went) but what gets it for me is this is topped off by first class SERVICE. A pub not to be missed if you are in the SE23/SE6 borders.
Camraboy - 13 Sep 2008 17:37
This is a brilliant old school Irish pub. I come here every Thursday after 5-a-side football and the welcome is always great. The impecably polite barstuff wear shirts and ties and remember what you do and what you drink. Musicians come and play every Thursday too.
Good-sized screens showing football when it's on.
Landlord buys drinks at Christmas.
If you buy a big round and there's Guiness in it then they bring the Guiness over to you, even if you're sitting outside.
A wide range of drinkers from young to old, geezers sitting there reading books.
Pubs like they used to be and how they should be.
Brockleydrinks - 29 Aug 2008 15:26
Huge garden at the back.

In full bloom with plenty of seating. No side access so people may not be aware of this.

Plenty of character - a proper pub.
ArhurPint - 5 Jul 2008 19:14
Beautiful unspoiled interior with golf-themed décor. Staffed by gentlemen in shirts and ties serving fine Harveys and Westerham beers when I visited. A proper London pub, well worth a visit if tradition means anything to you.

Cheers,

Alph_river - 29 Jun 2008 13:13
Aargghh - dont wish to steal the limelight but meant to say: in all the pubs I go to and have been - you would not believe the banter in this place (even if you can't understand all of it - sorry Chris). Seriously, its second to none. By the way, if you play flute, penny-whistle, fiddle, bodhran, spoons, squeezebox etc - join in the T'ursday session! Never see accoustic guitar!!
operationmindcrime - 3 Jun 2008 18:18
Absolutely! I've been going for...what...2.5 - 3 years or so. Spent 1/2 of that trying to get the rest of our tribe (SelCamra) there. I do Geoff - live locally that is! Year well done guys. Always a Westerham on - ALWAYS in top form (told W'ham never to stop the supply chain here). Lovely old 3 barred, dark wood walled, cosy, interesting ex courgae pub ran by a team of exceptionally friendly Irish gents - the old way! Lovely guys (even Chris!!). Big garden too! Slap on the S Circular/Stanstead Rd literally 5 mins west of Catford. Long may they rein. (thursday night is fiddles night! Not stupid prices!!
operationmindcrime - 3 Jun 2008 18:01
Says it all really! http://www.selcamra.org.uk/PuboftheYear.htm
(well done to Con, Terry and the rest of the team)
baggydave - 16 Mar 2008 11:23
Very nice pub, welcoming bar staff with an excellent manner and a good bunch of upstanding regulars. Selection of beers isn't bad, though not real ale standards. Would happily make it my local.
iddleyiddle - 11 Sep 2007 21:38
An absolute GEM and I try to pop in every time I am in the area. Traditional pub and great atmosphere. The London Pride tastes great.
JustCallMeH - 15 Jul 2007 12:16
A cracking little pub. Good beer, friendly landlord and locals. It's also a tremendous survivor, still retaining three separate rooms with fittings that probably going back to the 1920s. My only regret is I don't live locally.
(A little curiosity is that you can walk straight across the serving area from the saloon to the lounge at the back).
g.brandwood - 26 May 2007 11:17
An okay pub, But a bit too clicky and the locals are not very inviting.
anonymous - 16 Jan 2007 21:46
Cleanest pint ive had in the area the beer is obviously weel kept. Friendly staff as well.
birdnhandroger - 16 Jan 2007 14:04
NICE DECENT BOOZER DOES WHAT IT SAYS ON THE DOOR..

LIKE IT

VERY MUCH
12many - 6 Jan 2007 14:53
There was a time when it was a given that all pubs would have plush chintzy seating, frosted windows, separate bars and smoking would be compulsory. Then, one day, somebody who carried a clipboard for a living said: "I know, why don't we turn most of the pubs into restaurants and make much more money. Only let's pretend that they're still pubs but sneakily stick cutlery and menus on every table so that the customers feel uneasy if they're not eating. Oh, and while we're at it, let's knock down all the walls and turn them into great big open spaces and put in clear windows just to really intimidate the poor sods".

So what happened then was that all the people who enjoyed drinking and smoking and having a convivial chat with the folk sitting on the opposite side of the snug and eating nothing more than the occasional packet of crisps while doing it had nowhere to go. This was very nearly the end of civillised life as we knew it.

But before you all leave for somewhere with a decent drinking culture - Holland or northern Belgium for instance - note this: a plucky group of renegades has banded together and is holding fast the barricades at the last place in London that understands what going to the pub used to be about. So if you like drinking good beer, smoking a lot, talking convivially with strangers and having the occasional chese and onion toastie this is the place for you. But then you knew that already didn't you?
ToffeeJim - 4 Dec 2006 00:38
Agree with all the previuos postings. This is a lovely little pub full of character. A real old fashioned gem that you'd thought would've disappeared yonks ago. Can be a bit smokey but well worth the visit.
suppinguy - 25 Nov 2006 02:03
great atmosphere, great staff, charming landlord. cannot fault this place.
localbloke - 17 Nov 2006 14:11
Surely the most authentic boozer in SE23. Walking into here is like stepping back in time. Three characterful rooms all served by a central bar. The small public bar is a little gem of dark wood panelling and unpretentious eating, and you almost feel like you are back in the 1950s. From here, rather uniquely, you have to walk through the serving area to get to a second room. This room is another magnificently traditional place, dark and cosy, with small tables definitely designed for drinking and not eating, each with several little stools beside them – just as it should be. Compare this with all the dreaded gastro-pubs with their high, square tables and straight-backed chairs. Follow the bar around a bit more and you reach the third room, a brighter area with plenty of stools alongside the bar – compare this with Wetherspoon’s and all the rest, who won’t allow any stools at the bar for fear of a bit of smoke getting up their employees’ noses.

Three real ales were available. I had a London Pride in great condition. SPA (Special Pale Ale) from some Kentish brewer was also on. I forget what the third one was; it may have been Courage Best.

A superb pub and I will definitely be going back. I hope this place never changes.

karloff - 5 Nov 2006 13:05
This is my husband's local - he's Irish and this is an Irish pub: not a plastic Irish place like some of the chain pubs. It is certainly cosy - I sometimes find it almost too small but I appreciate it for its good atmosphere and courteous service. There is live Irish music once a month. I did go to the quiz night once a year ago - fortunately, didn't hear any sick humour; hope tat is thing of past?
spincat - 19 Jun 2006 06:55
i think this pub is great, the staff are so friendly and always rememeber you and what you drink even if its been ages since you've been there.this is a proper PUB, which is a nice change from all the trendy bar-pubs that are opening in forest hill. if you want a good knees up in a boozer, this is the place to go. nice garden
smokie_tearz - 29 Jan 2006 17:07
i really like this pub for a good old cosy sunday next to the warm fire. drinks are cheap, only problem is the smokey atmosphere accumulates a bit too much.
pachabelle82 - 29 Apr 2005 13:36
Excellent local, cosy on the inside, friendly staff, excellent beer. If you can't take the odd joke during a quiz I dont think you should be in ANY pub, staff at home and watch BBC1.
John - 28 Jun 2004 02:13
Nice and cosy, but beware the casual racism, which sometimes rears its ugly head on quiz night. If there's been a tragedy involving ethnic minorities that week you can be sure most of the teams will have sick names inspired by the event. It's a shame because - blokey Enoch Powell tendencies aside - it's a nice, traditional pub, run by friendly and courteous staff. And any hostelry where Guinness is poured properly and brought to your table once its settled is definitely worth a visit.
mark - 29 Feb 2004 19:53
This pub is about as irish as my arse! overpriced small and not good
Ian - 22 Jun 2003 23:55
Friendly Irish run local, football on especially Celtic. Pub Quiz in winter months. Not at all intimidating.
Kate Blatherwick - 4 Jun 2003 23:52

got anything to say about this pub?

Please read our comments policy before posting.
Only registered users can post reviews. Please log in. If you don't have an account yet, register here.

 

Blog | Forums | Copyright Neransk Limited 2001-2008. All Rights Reserved.